As if adopting Agile wasn’t scary enough, Keith Richards from KRC talked about the 8 dangers of Agile at the APM conference last month. And here they are:
It arrives bottom up
“We don’t really want the techies taking over the organisation,” said Keith. “This bottom up stuff is a bit dangerous.” He made the point that Agile isn’t something that should grow organically from the IT department. Make sure your Agile deployment is a conscious decision.
It looks simple
“It if was simple we wouldn’t need to be trained up in PRINCE2®,” he said. My view is that everything is simple when you know how it works, but Agile looks deceptively simple from the outside. Be cautious with your implementation, Keith recommended.
It’s mixing oil with water
Agile has a particular approach to governance that doesn’t sit well with some heavy corporate governance structures. Agile (in my opinion) isn’t anti-management, but it is nimble. Some companies aren’t nimble, so give some thought to how the two approaches will sit comfortably together.
You start with timeboxing
Timeboxing is the Agile approach to getting things done by a fixed date. Chunks of work are packaged up and delivered at the end of a timebox, and this means that projects deliver on time. I honestly thought timeboxing would be a good place to start, but Keith flagged this as a potential danger. Put Agile into a wider context, he suggested. This means not starting with timeboxing, but starting instead with an education campaign and really understanding what you are setting out to do.
A full PMI-ACP exam prep course. Self-paced with video training modules, you'll quickly be on your way to your agile certification. We love this course from respected trainer Cornelius Fichtner and it's a cost-effective way to prepare for your exam. Upgrades available to add on the exam simulator and study guidebooks.
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you #ad
“Who’s going to pull this together?” Keith asked. You can’t rely on teams to be self-managing when there are numerous people or multiple strands involved in a project. People need a single point of contact.
It grows virally
Don’t let Agile spread virally, Keith warned. While this might work for some things (like adopting a corporate wiki), it won’t work with Agile. You will end up with variants that don’t work and no consistent understanding of what Agile is all about.
The people upstairs don’t get it
This is a very real danger, but I would argue that it’s a problem for all project management approaches, not just agile ways of doing things. If you don’t have senior stakeholder buy in and understanding, making any type of process or methodology change is going to be very difficult. You can counter this danger by increasing your education campaign to cover those stakeholders, as well as the people who’ll be doing the doing.
The tools drive the transition
Keith flagged this as a danger for Agile implementations, but again I feel this is a danger for any change in methodology. Don’t let tools drive the transition to a new way of working. The tools should support your new processes, not the other way round. In the case of Agile, don’t buy some kind of software to support development and then hope it will ‘fix’ everything. Software doesn’t roll out new processes – you do.
What other dangers have you come across from deploying Agile on your projects? Or from deploying any new project approach, for that matter?
Elizabeth Harrin is a Fellow of the Association for Project Management in the UK, a trainer, mentor and author. She helps managers juggle their projects and ditch the overwhelm, making tools and techniques work in the real world. Elizabeth is also the founder of the Project Management Rebels community, a teaching-led mentoring group for professionals. She's written several books for project managers including Managing Multiple Projects.
This episode of my video diary from Dallas/Fort Worth, Texas, covers Day 1 of PMI’s Global Congress North America. Thanks to Brenda for taking part in this video. The speaker whose name she can’t remember is John Furlong, CEO of the Vancouver Organizing Committee, who spearheaded the 2010 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games. Disclosure: PMI…
Eric Jenett, founder member of PMI and PMI Fellow, died yesterday aged 88. Mr Jenett was the very first person to become a PMP. He received a Master’s degree in Chemical Engineering from Columbia University and then spent much of his career with Brown and Root in Houston, Texas. He was also a founding member…
It’s the night before I fly to Dublin to speak at a PMI Ireland Chapter event. I’m all organised and sitting relaxing with a glass of wine, my bag packed in the hall for the early morning flight. Ha! Did you honestly think that was true? In reality I’m sweeping 600 peas off the floor…
It doesn’t bode well when some of the brightest IT minds in the country can’t get the projector to work. Sue Black covered it up well but yesterday’s BCS event didn’t get off to a flying start. The evening was to discuss the perennial question of the lack of women in technical jobs and what…
I’m not a great one for making resolutions so this year I thought I’d take a different look at things. Instead of setting myself up for failure by making promises to do new things, I wanted to turn it on its head. Let’s look instead at the things to stop doing. Here are the 5…